Community of lawyers.
Common purpose.
Shared goals.

Robert C. Dortch, Jr. | Sellers Hinshaw Ayers Dortch & Lyons PA | Charlotte

Claire Modlin



Claire is the Vice President of Claims. She joined Lawyers Mutual in 2017 and previously served in the role of Underwriter and Senior Claims Counsel. Prior to joining Lawyers Mutual, she practiced in the areas of civil litigation, medical malpractice defense, insurance defense, and transportation. Claire actively practiced in both large and medium-sized firms in North Carolina for 22 years.  You can reach Claire at 800.662.8843 or at claire@lawyersmutualnc.com. 

misseddeadline
First the bad news: blown statutes of limitation and other critical deadlines are the leading cause of malpractice claims.

The good news: with a little effort and the right systems, you can dramatically reduce the risk in your law office.

“Missed deadlines remain the number one source of claims at Lawyers Mutual,” writes LM Vice President of Claims Claire Modlin. “Missed deadlines can include missed statutes of limitations, missed deadlines to obtain alias and pluries summons, missed discovery deadlines, and missed appellate deadlines. Having a good docketing and calendaring system, as well as a routine surrounding deadlines, can help avoid this all-too-common mistake.”

Everyone makes mistakes. When it happens to you, Lawyers Mutual has your back. For nearly half a century, Lawyers Mutual has been the smart choice for professional liability coverage for North Carolina attorneys. We cover the state from Murphy to Manteo. We insure large firms, solo practitioners and everyone in between. We help new lawyers enter the profession with confidence, and we help keep seasoned veterans safe and successful. The numbers speak for themselves. Lawyers Mutual has been in business since 1977, making us the only insurance carrier to provide continuous protection over that period. Today we insure more than 8000 lawyers in North Carolina. Most of them will stick with us until they retire. Why? Because they know we are here for them today and will be here tomorrow, bringing protection and peace of mind in turbulent times. Visit our website, give us a call, or ask a colleague why Lawyers Mutual is the smart choice for liability coverage.

 

Here are some strategies to help you avoid missed deadlines, courtesy of Claire Modlin in this article for Lawyers Mutual:

  • Break a deadline up into multiple small tasks. Schedule having a draft of the complaint done by the 6-month mark.  Send the draft complaint to the client for review by the 5-month mark. Send the final draft for verification by your client at the 4-month mark.  Docket getting the complaint filed by the 3-month mark. 
  • Put multiple docket entries on the calendar surrounding a deadline. If you only docket the final deadline, you risk a legal malpractice claim.  Instead, give yourself a cushion with multiple dates. For example, if you have an expert designation approaching, put in a reminder notice with ample time to remedy any problems, then a second reminder that the deadline is getting close and finally a reminder that the deadline will be missed if action is not taken.    
  • Establish a routine regarding docketing deadlines. If possible, designate one person to enter deadlines on a calendar that you and all your support staff can access. Either you, an associate or another support person should be responsible for double-checking that the deadline has been entered and that the deadline is accurate. Set aside a regular time each week where you review any upcoming deadlines with your associates and support staff team. 

Unfortunately, even with the best system in place, mistakes can happen. If you do find that you have missed a deadline, reach out to the claims department at Lawyers Mutual to see if there are any claims repair options.  

Claire Modlin is the Vice President of Claims at Lawyers Mutual. Prior to joining Lawyers Mutual, she practiced in the areas of civil litigation, medical malpractice defense, insurance defense, and transportation. She worked in both large and medium-sized firms in North Carolina for 22 years. You can reach Claire at 800.662.8843 or at claire@lawyersmutualnc.com. 

SOURCE: Common Litigation Errors: Missed Deadlines – Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company (lawyersmutualnc.com)

Why choose Lawyers Mutual for your financial protection? One reason is experience. Lawyers Mutual has been in business since 1977 and insures more than 8000 lawyers in North Carolina. We’ve been providing continuous protection from professional liability to NC lawyers longer than any other insurance company. Another reason is stability. The company’s financial strength is absolute. Since 1999, Lawyers Mutual has paid dividends fourteen times, with more than $8 million dollars returned to policyholders since 2011. Want even more reasons? Visit our website, give us a call, or ask a colleague why Lawyers Mutual is the smart choice for liability coverage.

 

Missed deadlines remain the number one source of claims at Lawyers Mutual. Although it appears missed deadlines would be an easy error to avoid, we see it all too frequently. Missed deadlines can include missed statutes of limitations, missed deadlines to obtain alias and pluries summons, missed discovery deadlines, and missed appellate deadlines. Having a good docketing and calendaring system, as well as a routine surrounding deadlines, can help avoid this all-too-common mistake. 

Here are a few strategies that may help:

  • Break a deadline up into multiple small tasks. Schedule having a draft of the complaint done by the 6-month mark.  Send the draft complaint to the client for review by the 5-month mark. Send the final draft for verification by your client at the 4-month mark.  Docket getting the complaint filed by the 3-month mark. 
  • Put multiple docket entries on the calendar surrounding a deadline. If you only docket the final deadline, you risk a legal malpractice claim.  Instead, give yourself a cushion with multiple dates. For example, if you have an expert designation approaching, put in a reminder notice with ample time to remedy any problems, then a second reminder that the deadline is getting close and finally a reminder that the deadline will be missed if action is not taken.    
  • Establish a routine regarding docketing deadlines. If possible, designate one person to enter deadlines on a calendar that you and all your support staff can access. Either you, an associate or another support person should be responsible for double-checking that the deadline has been entered and that the deadline is accurate. Set aside a regular time each week where you review any upcoming deadlines with your associates and support staff team. 

Unfortunately, even with the best system in place, mistakes can happen. If you do find that you have missed a deadline, reach out to the claims department at Lawyers Mutual to see if there are any claims repair options. 

 

Over the last few years, Lawyers Mutual has seen an increase in Estates and Trusts (E&T) claims. In 2021, E&T claims were the third most common claims according to area of practice. Only Plaintiff’s personal injury and residential real estate generated more claims by practice area. Errors occur in both estate planning and estate administration. Two common E&T errors are:

Disbursement Errors: Disbursement errors are common in estate administration. Disbursement errors can include overpayment to one or more beneficiaries, leaving out beneficiaries or payment to the incorrect beneficiary. Once a disbursement error has been made, it can be difficult to get the money returned. Although you can request that the person who received the overpayment return the money and even pursue legal action, it may be difficult to recover the overpayment, especially if the money has already been spent. To prevent disbursement errors, identify the beneficiaries early in the process. Attempt to discern who the beneficiaries are through your client, the personal representative of the estate, public records searches, asking family members or any other means. Do not rush the process.  

Defining Scope of Representation: When assisting a client with estate planning, it is very important to communicate the scope of your representation, know who your client is and clearly delineate both in your engagement letter. Oftentimes, an adult child will accompany an elderly parent to a meeting with the attorney to draft estate planning documents. It is important for the attorney to communicate to the adult child that the client is the parent. The attorney should meet with the parent separately to assess the parent’s wishes regarding his or her estate planning documents. Although the adult child may be well-intentioned, other beneficiaries may raise issues of undue influence by the adult child and could potentially file a will caveat proceeding. Lawyers Mutual commonly sees the drafting attorney get pulled into these will caveat proceedings through a subpoena for his or her file and/or testimony.  At times, the attorney also gets named as a defendant in connection with the litigation. These claims are often emotionally charged and can lead to prolonged litigation. Protect yourself on the front end by having a clearly defined engagement letter and meeting with your client separately from any other family members. If you have questions about the testator’s capacity or competence or are concerned about undue influence, refer your client to a mental health professional for evaluation. NC Formal Ethics Opinion 2006 FEO 11 states that “a lawyer may not, at the request of a third party, prepare documents, such as a will or trust instrument, that purport to speak solely for principal without consulting with, exercising independent professional judgment on behalf of, and obtaining consent from the principal.”  To read the full opinion, click here:  https://www.ncbar.gov/for-lawyers/ethics/adopted-opinions/2006-formal-ethics-opinion-11/

E&T is a complicated area of law. If handling an E&T matter is outside your area of expertise, it is advisable to refer the potential client to a colleague who has more experience in the area. Dabbling in areas of practice outside your expertise often leads to errors and eventual claims against you for professional malpractice.  

Wire fraud was a problem prior to Covid-19; however, with the increase in remote work spurred by the pandemic, wire fraud has increased. Cyber-attacks have occurred in every sector of life and attorneys are not immune.  In fact, real estate attorneys are a prime target for cyber criminals. One of the most common scenarios is the Business Email Compromise scam where the email of one of the parties to the transaction (the attorney, paralegal, real estate agent, mortgage broker or buyer) is hacked. One way to prevent entrusted funds from being wired to a hacker is to call a known number prior to wiring any funds.  In addition, warn your clients not to trust any changes to wiring instructions.  

Every Lawyers Mutual policy issued has the Financial Fraud Exclusionary Endorsement. Within the endorsement is the Safe Harbor which requires attorneys in real estate transactions to adhere to the following provisions: 

  1. Incoming Wire Protection:  Insist that every new client, for every new matter, receive an engagement letter that clearly states the following: “BEFORE SENDING ANY WIRE, CALL OUR OFFICE TO VERIFY THE INSTRUCTIONS. WE WILL NOT CHANGE WIRING INSTRUCTIONS.  IF YOU RECEIVE WIRING INSTRUCTIONS FOR A DIFFERENT BANK, BRANCH LOCATION, ACCOUNT NAME OR ACCOUNT NUMBER, THEY SHOULD BE PRESUMED TO BE FRAUDULENT. DO NOT SEND ANY FUNDS AND CONTACT OUR OFFICE IMMEDIATELY.  FAILURE TO FOLLOW THIS PROCEDURE ENDANGERS YOUR FUNDS.”  Advise your client of the above instructions, require him or her to sign the engagement letter and retain a signed copy for your file.  

  2. Outgoing Wire Protection: Before sending any money out of your trust account via wire, obtain a written, original, notarized disbursement instruction authorizing the wiring or electronic transmission of the funds.

Further, make sure you are taking steps to actively protect your data and systems: multi-factor authentication, encrypted email (do not use Hotmail or gmail) and require yourself and staff to change passwords on a frequent basis and to have complicated passwords or passphrases.  

There have been repeated warnings and numerous articles by the NC State Bar, title companies, Lawyers Mutual and various other organizations regarding cybercrime. Wire fraud is not being taken lightly and attorneys may be disciplined by the State Bar if they do not take adequate precautions.  

We encourage all attorneys to obtain cyber coverage in the event of a cyber breach or wire fraud incident. Our subsidiary, Lawyers Insurance Agency, offers cyber products. For a cyber quote, contact Adam Pierce at adam@lawyersmutualnc.com or Kelly Gold at kelly@lawyersmutualnc.com.  

 

In 2021, litigation errors constituted one-third of all the claims reported to Lawyers Mutual. Plaintiff’s Personal Injury, under the litigation umbrella, constituted the single practice area with the most reported claims. Missed deadlines breed the most errors. The lack of a good calendaring and docket system is the main reason attorneys miss deadlines. Remote work and not being in the office with other attorneys and support staff has compounded this problem.  

Common litigation errors are:

Missed Statutes of Limitations:  The most common litigation error we see at Lawyers Mutual is missed statutes of limitations. Once the statute of limitations is missed, there is nothing we can do to remedy the error. Reasons for missing the statute of limitations include waiting until the last minute to file the Complaint, naming the wrong corporate defendant and not knowing the correct statute of limitations at the outset. We strongly encourage our insureds to not wait until the last month (and certainly not the last day) to file a lawsuit and not to take new engagements where the statute will run within 3 months of the initial engagement.  

Lapsed Alias and Pluries (A&P) summons:  If a defendant is not served within the time allowed for service, the action may be continued if the plaintiff obtains an endorsement or A&P summons.  Rule 4 states that if the endorsement or A&P summons is not obtained within 90 days after the date of issuance of the last preceding summons, the action is discontinued as to any defendant not served within the time allowed. A plaintiff can sue out another A&P summons after 90 days, but the action will be deemed to have commenced on the date of issuance of that new A&P summons. If the statute of limitations has expired, your action as to that defendant not served is barred by the statute of limitations.

Missed Discovery Deadlines: The most common (and consequential) discovery error is failure to respond to Request for Admissions. Request for Admissions are deemed admitted if not responded to by the deadline  This mistake can be remedied by filing a motion to permit withdrawal or amendment of the admissions. Of course, the motion will be within the discretion of the trial court and it is not guaranteed that it will be granted. If you are the Plaintiff and fail to respond to Request for Admissions, you can obtain your client’s permission to file a voluntary dismissal without prejudice (assuming you have not previously taken a dismissal of the action) and then re-file. Fortunately, the admissions will not carry over to the re-filed action.  

Missed litigation deadlines can have serious, and sometimes fatal, consequences to your case. Whether you use a computerized system or an old-fashioned tickler system, it is important to enter all deadlines in the system. You should make sure you set multiple advance warnings that the deadline is approaching. The deadlines should be put on not only your calendar, but also on your support staff calendars. You should schedule a regular time each week to review your calendar for all upcoming deadlines. Make sure to treat any and all litigation deadlines with care.  Also, train your staff on the importance of all litigation and discovery deadlines. A little prevention on the front-end can go a long way towards preventing claims.